Gasoline and Diesel Engines
Diesel engines and gasoline engines ultimately do the same thing; they power your vehicle. The majority of components internally and native to the engine itself are about the same, though they are built to different specifications. As each engine is different from others by design and manufacturer, and since my goal is to give you a good idea of the differences between the two types of engines, I will state them as general conditions. Generally, a diesel engine has fewer parts and fewer, less complicated mechanical operations. The goal of both types of engines is to propel your vehicle comfortably, powerfully and quietly. They achieve the goal and do the work in different methods, and they burn different fuels. Here are the main differences between a diesel engine and a gasoline engine, though yielding similar work.
Fuel - A gasoline engine runs on gasoline, or mixtures that are primarily gasoline. There are various octane ratings, various additives for one reason or another, and various methods of refinement, but the fuel is for all practical purposes, gasoline.
A diesel engine runs on diesel fuel, kerosene. It also comes in various refined products and grades for commercial use, industrial applications, farm and agricultural use, aviation, and automotive applications.
Fuel Delivery and Burning - A gasoline engine ingests a controlled mixture of gasoline and air, compresses it and then ignites the mixture with a spark. The ignition of the fuel mixture produces a force which is captured in a controlled manner, allowing the engine to fulfill the objective of work. These engines have a designed compression ratio range of about 7.5 to perhaps 12.5 to 1, meaning the volume of the air/gas mixture is reduced and compressed intentionally during the compression cycle of each piston and cylinder, based on the design and purpose of the engine, anywhere from 7.5 to 12.5 times. Gasoline engines can use either a carburetor or a fuel injection system to deliver the fuel to the cylinders, again depending on the design and intent of the engine. With a carburetor, often termed a normally aspirated engine, the fuel and air is mixed in the carburetor before it enters the intake manifold. The intake manifold then delivers the pre-mixed air/gas fuel mixture to the cylinders, all of them, during the intake stroke of each cylinder of the engine, through the cylinder's intake valve or valves. The mixture is then drawn in to the cylinder and both the intake and the exhaust valves subsequently close as part of the cycle. The opening and closing of the valves, lifting and depressing of the pistons within the cylinders, drawing in and exhausting of fuel and gases is controlled in a series of mechanical movements through the camshaft, which is geared directly or indirectly to the crankshaft. That is also synchronized with the time that a spark plug ignites the mixture. The whole process is generally called the "engine timing". By contrast, in a typical fuel injection system, the fuel, gas in this case, is injected just prior to the engine's cylinder intake stroke at the individual cylinder's intake valve or valves. A metered, generally by computer, amount of air is mixed INSIDE the cylinder with the injected fuel. From that point, the valve, timing, compression, ignition and work process is the same as a carburetor fed gasoline engine.
A diesel engine ingests only air, also compresses it (much more than in a gasoline engine), then injects the fuel into the highly compressed (thus highly heated) air. Contact of the fuel and the highly compressed, heated air ignites the fuel spontaneously. A diesel engine compresses ONLY THE AIR at a ratio of 14:1 to as high as 25:1. The higher compression ratio of the diesel engine leads to better overall engine efficiency. Most diesel engines use direct fuel injection (often know as DFI or DI), that is to say the diesel fuel is injected directly into the cylinder, or a narrow port leading to the cylinder. Since the diesel engine has no spark plugs, a process entirely different from that of a gasoline engine, the air it ingests is compressed (only the air), the fuel is injected directly into the cylinder at the point in the cylinder cycle of maximum compression, where the heat caused by the air compression ignites (explodes) the fuel. Upon combustion, work takes place. There are refinements for when the engine and air compression will NOT ignite the fuel, though that generally happens only in cold weather and when the engine if first started.
Conclusions - By comparison to gasoline fuel vehicles, diesel fuel engines are generally more fuel efficient. They often get better mileage and are commonly less complex. They don't use spark plugs or any form of an ignition system, thus requiring less required maintenance, perhaps even less periodic maintenance to the main engine. Diesel engines produce more torque, and they tend to be more durable. However, they also create more noise, have a dirty, visible exhaust emission, they can be touchy and difficult to start in extremely cold weather and they sometimes require more invasive routine maintenance than gasoline engines. Because the "pressures" inside the engine are much higher than in gasoline engines, the vibrations and shock forces on the engine are also higher. The block , pistons, crankshaft and other internal parts must be tougher than those used in gas engines. The initial cost of the engine and the cost of parts is usually higher for diesel. Fuel is also not as readily available to the average motorist. While there are more and more automotive diesel engines and vehicles each year, still the vast majority of applications are for industrial and heavy work applications, such as trucks, tractors and even trains.
Options to the EXTERNAL function of the engine, such as power brakes, power steering, air conditioning, cooling, alternation and the like, are more or less identical in operation on either engine type. One difference that comes to mind is the starter and the battery to turn the starter. Since the compression of the engine works AGAINST the starter spinning the engine in the starting process, the starter and hence the battery must be stronger and more powerful. Diesel engines generate more heat because they do more work. Both require adequate lubrication, though, in a general, very non-descript sense, oil for lubrication in a diesel engine gets dirtier quicker.
While these are very broad, common and non-specific statements of differences, they do serve as a generalized portrayal of the operational features of the engine types.
|
